Most brokers dismissive of BoE economist’s rate-cut warning

Published on

The vast majority of mortgage intermediaries have rejected the Bank of England chief economist Huw Pill’s suggestion that interest rates are falling too quickly, according to new polling from specialist lender Landbay.

In a survey conducted in June, Landbay asked brokers whether they agreed with Pill’s recent claim that rates were coming down “too fast.” Just 13% said they supported his view, while 82% said they did not. The remaining 5% were unsure.

The results highlight a striking divide between market sentiment and the caution voiced by Pill, who joined the Bank as chief economist in 2021 and also sits on the Monetary Policy Committee.

Speaking at a recent conference hosted by the London School of Economics, Pill warned that inflationary pressures in the UK could prove more persistent than currently forecast, implying that the Bank may need to take a more forceful or sustained approach to monetary tightening than investors expect.

Unhappy: Pill

He reiterated concerns that Britain may face structural inflation challenges akin to those seen in the 1970s and 1980s, citing changes in wage and price-setting behaviour.

While the Bank’s central forecast points to inflation returning to its 2% target by early 2027, Pill stressed that this projection should not be interpreted as an endorsement of market expectations for a smooth path of rate cuts.

“I remain concerned that we have seen a sort of structural change in price and wage-setting behaviour,” he said.

“Maybe driven by the type of things that were involved in models of the inflation process from the ’70s and ’80s.”

Pill opposed the MPC’s quarter-point cut in May, which brought the base rate down to 4.25%, and has urged a pause in further reductions. Rather than halting the overall path of monetary easing, he has argued for a “skip” this quarter to allow policymakers more time to assess underlying economic conditions.

Rob Stanton, sales and distribution director at Landbay, said: “Huw Pill has been a consistent voice of caution while the central bank has been making rate reductions. He’s not alone: both he and Catherine Mann have advocated for rates to be held recently.

“While intermediaries clearly don’t hold with his views, the brokers we have polled are not outliers: the majority of the MPC opted for a quarter-point reduction in rates to 4.25% recently – and there’s a cohort of the MPC calling for a sharper, half-point cut in rates given weak economic growth and dangers, including the global trade conflict.”

COMMENT ON MORTGAGE SOUP

We want to hear from you!
Leave a comment and get the conversation started.
You need to register to post, so please login or sign up below.

Latest articles

Lloyds ad banned over misleading £19.5bn housing claim

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has ruled that a Lloyds Banking Group advertisement overstated...

Reeves mulls Capital Gains Tax on high-value homes as Treasury seeks £40bn

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is considering ending the capital gains tax (CGT) exemption on high-value...

Landbay unveils new free valuation options and cuts rates on two-year fixes

Buy-to-let lender Landbay has expanded its Summer Special range with the launch of four...

Commuter hotspots offer affordability lifeline as office returns pick up

With more employees heading back into the office commuting is once again shaping homebuying...

Heather Small and Bootleg Beatles to headline first Sort Ball in Manchester

Heather Small and The Bootleg Beatles have been announced as the headline performers for...

Latest publication

Latest opinions

Tuning into later life lending conversations

There are certain conversations in our profession that can genuinely change the course of...

Right of Light risks: a looming shadow over construction projects

Gone are the days when a Right of Light infringement could be swiftly dealt...

Could a move to ‘enhanced advice’ also mean mandatory protection conversations?

The FCA’s recent Mortgage Market Discussion Paper (DP25/2) has got the industry talking about...

Take off the rose-tinted glasses and stop chasing a rate cut

Every six weeks the financial world raises its eyebrows at the prospect of a...

Other news

Lloyds ad banned over misleading £19.5bn housing claim

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has ruled that a Lloyds Banking Group advertisement overstated...

Reeves mulls Capital Gains Tax on high-value homes as Treasury seeks £40bn

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is considering ending the capital gains tax (CGT) exemption on high-value...

Landbay unveils new free valuation options and cuts rates on two-year fixes

Buy-to-let lender Landbay has expanded its Summer Special range with the launch of four...