High Court rules in favour of Cirencester Friendly

Published on

The High Court in London this week agreed to set aside two Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) awards made in 2010 and 2012 and state that payment could not be enforced against the Cirencester Friendly Society.

High Court Judge Richard Seymour decided that Christopher Parkin, a former member of Cirencester Friendly Society Limited, acted fraudulently when applying for individual income protection insurance cover in 2007, when submitting his claim (which started within two months of Parkin becoming a member) and when involving the FOS.

The Society proactively asked the Court to set aside the two awards arising from Parkin’s complaints to the Financial Ombudsman Service and declare that the awards were not enforceable.

Paul Hudson, CEO of the Society, said: “I am very pleased that the Judge, in arriving at his considered decision, helped the Society to protect the interests of over 34,000 current members and to send a clear message that fraud will not be tolerated as it potentially impacts upon all.

“The Society is committed to supporting its members and the actions of Mr Parkin undermine genuine claimants who rely on the Society when they need our help. For a number of years now we have been very transparent about our claims payment record. In 2014, 94% of claims were paid to the value of £3.3 million in sick pay benefit. As a mutual, the Society is owned by its members and we exist to serve them. We did not enter this action lightly and it has been a long and stressful process but thankfully the truth came out and justice was served.”

The society said that at the outset Parkin’s application involved inadequate disclosure and if complete and accurate information had been disclosed the application would not have been accepted and Parkin would not have been offered membership. The FOS instead required the society to consider the claim (which led to a £19,000 payment which included penalty interest at 8%) and later in connection with a second complaint regarding an on-going claim the FOS wanted the society to pay a further significant sum of money. Believing there to have been fraud against the society and the FOS, the society wanted the court to consider the evidence.

The ruling in Cirencester Friendly Society Limited v Christopher Parkin on 12 May 2015 held that Parkin had defrauded the Society and the FOS, that the £19,000 already paid must be returned to the society and that no payment be made regarding the second FOS award. The society said it was right to say that due to fraud at the application, the contract should in accordance with legal principles be treated as if it had never existed.

Kennedys’ partner, Helen Tilley, who acted on behalf of the Society, said: “Fraud is a serious allegation and is not made lightly. Cogent evidence impressed the Court Judge, and Court proceedings was the appropriate forum through which to consider allegations of this nature.

“The judgment may see renewed confidence in insurers highlighting that the Court is an alternative and appropriate forum to deal with serious fraud allegations.”

COMMENT ON MORTGAGE SOUP

We want to hear from you!
Leave a comment and get the conversation started.
You need to register to post, so please login or sign up below.

Latest articles

Croydon tops list of most in-demand locations among UK homebuyers

Croydon has emerged as the most popular location for homebuyers across the UK, according...

Newcastle cuts 95% LTV rates and improves cashback terms for first-time buyers

Newcastle for Intermediaries has reduced rates across its 95% loan-to-value (LTV) mortgage range, cutting...

Word On The Street appoints first broker

Word On The Street, the specialist property finance brokerage, has appointed Ben Hartley as...

Younger generations look to pensions and property for retirement security

Millennials and Generation Z are increasingly turning to both pensions and property to secure...

SMEs unprepared for net zero rules as 2026 reporting deadline approaches

Most small and medium-sized businesses remain unprepared for new sustainability reporting standards, with just...

Latest publication

Latest opinions

Tuning into later life lending conversations

There are certain conversations in our profession that can genuinely change the course of...

Right of Light risks: a looming shadow over construction projects

Gone are the days when a Right of Light infringement could be swiftly dealt...

Could a move to ‘enhanced advice’ also mean mandatory protection conversations?

The FCA’s recent Mortgage Market Discussion Paper (DP25/2) has got the industry talking about...

Take off the rose-tinted glasses and stop chasing a rate cut

Every six weeks the financial world raises its eyebrows at the prospect of a...

Other news

Croydon tops list of most in-demand locations among UK homebuyers

Croydon has emerged as the most popular location for homebuyers across the UK, according...

Newcastle cuts 95% LTV rates and improves cashback terms for first-time buyers

Newcastle for Intermediaries has reduced rates across its 95% loan-to-value (LTV) mortgage range, cutting...

Word On The Street appoints first broker

Word On The Street, the specialist property finance brokerage, has appointed Ben Hartley as...