COMMENT: Twelfth night is no comedy of errors

Published on

Eddie Goldsmith , senior partner at Goldsmith Williams, has more bad news for consumers

You may be interested to know that a recent ruling in the High Court has dealt another blow to consumers wanting to write off their debts.

Borrowers have been using the provisions of the Consumer Credit Act to request a copy of their credit agreement to see whether the document is unenforceable or not. If a lender is unable to provide a copy of the agreement, borrowers have been trying to obtain an order from the court to have the debt wiped out.

However, the ruling, made by Judge Waksman in the Manchester High Court, means that banks need only provide borrowers with a ‘reconstituted’ version of their credit card agreement, which can be made from sources other than the signed document itself. The absence of an original signed agreement does not, therefore, mean that borrowers can simply walk away from their debt obligations. This means that financial institutions have the right to enforce debts even when a borrower’s original loan agreement has been lost or destroyed and a copy cannot be provided within 12 days, as required by the Consumer Credit Act.

This ruling acts as another reminder to brokers that there are no easy ‘get out of jail free’ cards for clients with mounting debt problems. If lenders have treated borrowers fairly, then borrowers remain obliged to repay their debts, even if their lender no longer has a copy of their original loan documentation.

Judge Waksman has criticised some borrowers for trying to avoid repaying their debts by challenging lenders to produce a valid copy of their loan agreement, saying that “the absence of a copy of signed executed agreement is no evidence that such an agreement was not made.””

COMMENT ON MORTGAGE SOUP

We want to hear from you!
Leave a comment and get the conversation started.
You need to register to post, so please login or sign up below.

Latest articles

First-time buyers favour ‘forever homes’

First-time buyers are increasingly opting for larger homes and longer mortgage terms as they...

OPDA launches upgraded framework to cut delays in transactions

The Open Property Data Association (OPDA) has unveiled version 3.5 of its Property Data...

Majority of landlords plan to hold their ground, Landbay survey shows

Buy-to-let landlords are demonstrating renewed confidence in the private rented sector, with a majority...

One third of people relying on inheritance to secure retirement income

Nearly one in three people believe they will need an inheritance to help fund...

Fear of rejection deters thousands from applying for a mortgage

More than a third of would-be homebuyers say the fear of being rejected is...

Latest publication

Other news

First-time buyers favour ‘forever homes’

First-time buyers are increasingly opting for larger homes and longer mortgage terms as they...

OPDA launches upgraded framework to cut delays in transactions

The Open Property Data Association (OPDA) has unveiled version 3.5 of its Property Data...

Majority of landlords plan to hold their ground, Landbay survey shows

Buy-to-let landlords are demonstrating renewed confidence in the private rented sector, with a majority...